Compare Bills
Put two bills side by side — summaries, sponsors, arguments, and votes.
Upland Basin Permitting Reform
Primary Sponsor
Norman SandersonRepublicanLast Action
Ref To Com On Rules and Operations of the Senate2025-03-26
Vote Breakdown
No floor votes recorded.
Plain Language Summary
This bill creates a streamlined permitting process for upland basins—marinas built by excavating land above the waterline to hold 10 or more boats. The bill sets specific environmental criteria (dissolved oxygen levels, wetland impact limits, buffers, and water quality standards) and requires state agencies to approve applications within 60 days if these criteria are met, with automatic approval if agencies miss the deadline.
Arguments in Favor
- •Supporters argue this bill benefits waterfront property owners by providing clearer, faster access to state waters through upland basins rather than traditional open-water marinas.
- •They contend that upland basins reduce storm debris impacts, preserve water quality when properly designed, decrease the need for onshore parking, and allow use of new technologies to maintain dissolved oxygen levels.
- •The streamlined 60-day approval timeline is intended to reduce bureaucratic delays while still protecting environmental standards.
Arguments Against
- •Opponents worry the bill weakens environmental protections by creating a presumption of compliance with water quality and wetland standards once the listed criteria are met, potentially limiting case-by-case environmental review.
- •They express concerns about the automatic approval provision if agencies fail to meet deadlines, which could incentivize rushing reviews, and about exemptions from stormwater management requirements.
- •Critics also question whether 24 months of monitoring is sufficient to ensure long-term water quality and whether dissolved oxygen testing at only one reference point adequately protects surrounding ecosystems.
Second Bill
Search for a bill to compare
Select a bill in each panel to see them compared side by side.